Monday, May 6, 2013

Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access (Part 4)


Alright! We're at the conclusion to this blog series on Acute Care! Here are the results of the last three case studies:

Case #6: To Move or Not To Move...
As mentioned many times, there is a definitive culture of stigma - fear - uncertainty - and/or anxiety in regards to intensive care. BUT! I always ask, "what bad may come if I do NOT see the patient?" In this case, my answers are these:

  • Yes. I move the patient.
  • Yes. I will attempt to mobilize this patient out of bed per his response to exertion.
  • Yes. The risk is worth it. The hazard of this patient further declining in musculoskeletal function with a decreased lung capacity is far worse than should this patient (once again) de-saturate to critical levels of oxygen.
  • And, what IF this patient crashes into the 70's? We've already been here. Worst case scenario is that the medical team must now pursue more aggressive oxygenation; the same place they just came from. Albert Einstein is famed for saying that "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." If we wish for the patient to return to health, he needs interventions other than bed rest and supplemental oxygen.
  • The discussion with the RCP & RN should include mentioning the risks and concerns of prolonged best rest. It should also include the above mentioned expectations of status quo versus active intervention. This discussion would also benefit from assurance that should the patient respond poorly to exertion, that such discovered limits would be expected & respected. Much of the time fear of change drives decision making more than goal of outcomes; every discussion with the above in mind for this setting has always lead to agreeability on all sides for mobilizing patients in the unit.
Ultimately for this patient, he was muscularly quite strong given two weeks of bed rest. He was able to transfer to a chair at moderate hand-held-assistance and was also able to participate in airway clearance, diaphragmatic breath, breath sequencing, and some gentle therapeutic exercise of the UE, LE, and trunk control. His saturation (surprise surprise) moved from the high 80's/low 90's clear into the mid-90's after 10 minutes. We were even able to wean off from 10L to 6L without any decline in oxygen saturation.

My vote on this one: TO MOVE!

Case #7: ICU, Ventilated trauma patient
Similar to the above case, the rationale I saw for this patient was fairly straight forward: if the patient doesn't maintain his physical capacity, he will lose it. At this point, the "only" barrier to function is really the physiological function of the lungs due to the trauma sustained. The patient was following commands and appropriate in mentation - I saw no danger and could gather no valid reason NOT to mobilize this patient. While the nurse expressed her nervousness regarding moving a ventilated patient, she respected my expertise and had confidence that I would not cause harm to the patient after a detailed explanation of my evaluation plan. I requested that she be present in the room as a second pair of eyes & hands to manage lines - and - off we went. The patient was able to stand, step, transfer, work on balance strategies for UE, LE, and trunk. He wrote on a piece of paper how thankful he was to be out of bed. Imagine the disservice of NOT having this patient be active during this state when all other systems are perfectly functional and safe!

I think there needs to be a cultural re-working of the ICU. In my opinion, the ICU is literally the SAFEST place a patient can be while staying in a hospital. Compared to other units, there is far more frequent and closer attention by the medical team than in any other unit - this includes the technological monitoring of patient status. Anecdotally, I can attest that the majority of the unanticipated events that befall rehab staff  during patient care tends to occur in their encounters outside of the ICU, where the monitoring is not as detailed.

I feel that the lesson of these first two cases in the ICU is that there must be a legitimate reason NOT to engage the patient in physical activity for physical therapists to defer evaluation and treatment. Otherwise, we are simply practicing Einsteinian insanity.

Case #8: Lumbar Disc Protrusion > 5mm; SURGERY?!
For this patient, I had a quick conversation with the nurse regarding MDT and the evidence behind early intervention for low back pain by physical therapists. About two minutes later, I was in the room introducing myself to the patient. I spent significant time educating the patient regarding the biomechanics of the spine, pain science, and expectations of the evaluation should the patient choose to proceed.

The patient expressed that he really did not want to have surgery. I explained that it is quite possible for us to avoid it should we be successful in reducing pain and restoring function. I started this patient with extension in lying on pillows then eventually moved onto full extensions while prone. Copious education and ice was to follow; the nurses were EXTREMELY helpful in reminding the patient not to position in spinal flexion as well as to encourage icing during the overnight short stay.


The next morning, a colleague of mine followed up with extensions in standing and the patient was able to ambulate pain free (minus a mild central soreness) as well as perform two flights of stairs. Surgery PREVENTED (at least for the moment) - the burden for a health system then would be to make sure this patient followed up with an outpatient physical therapist. Nevertheless, the lesson here is that even if imaging highly suggests the need for surgery, imaging is still imaging - the patient's response is what guides the direction of care.

Case #9: ATV Crash, Arm in two pieces?
Before we get anywhere: ALWAYS be your patient's #1 advocate! When patients start to complain that something doesn't quite feel right and you've screened out secondary gain, start looking deeper! Further investigation of the shoulder complex would have revealed that the patient was able to rotate the proximal humerus INDEPENDENT of the rest of his upper extremities.

Do NOT recommend this patient to be sent home. A closed reduction needs to REDUCE the fracture into one more-or-less "functional" piece; this patient felt like his arm was hanging out by itself - apart from his shoulder joint. If you feel the rotator cuff muscles shorten AND feel the greater tuberosity of the humerus move AND appreciated ZERO movement distal from the fracture site... the fracture was NOT reduced.

The orthopedic surgeon was paged and informed. He expressed much gratitude and after surgery, stated that this fracture site was SO clean that it was as if a laser cut the bone in two - reduction was impossible. The humerus was openly reduced and pinned. After the surgery, the patient was exuberantly thankful that someone intervened on his behalf. At first, the physician, nurse practitioner, and floor nurse were all trying to pass off the closed reduction as stable and good for home. The job of the physical therapist isn't necessarily to go with the flow - the job is to advocate for the patient's best interest.

Some closing thoughts:
I hope this blog series demonstrates the intensity, the breadth of scope, the situational awareness, and some of the political/communicative savvy required to be a consummate clinician in the acute care setting. These case studies were but a snapshot of some of my experiences and some of my colleagues experiences which is a DAILY part of acute care physical therapy.

Dr. Kyle Ridgeway expressed his concerns that should the profession truly move into an unrestricted direct access environment, the only realistic way for graduates to be able to recognize such complex and intense medical situations is through the exposure and training gleaned from the acute hospital environment. How else would one recognize a hypertensive crisis? How else can a graduate gather a sufficient auditory sample of auscultations to identify an S3 heart sound? I think its fairly clear that an acute care rotation should be a mandatory part of the #DPTstudent academic experience. Surely, we need to change the model of education for the acute care setting, both for the student and for the clinical instructor. I feel that acute care, with the medical complexities and instabilities involved, requires a graded exposure. I mentioned in PT TV Episode 12 that it should be much like a martial arts experience in training. Students start out as a white belt and are exposed to the simpler and less unstable situations. The content is then made more complex and intense over time. Also, much like martial arts, there is typically one teacher with several students. This is a prudent model for the acute care setting as schools can logistically operate for greater numbers of students per site, and, it would allow students to develop collaborative skill sets. Besides, so many other healthcare professions are ALREADY operating in this manner and have demonstrated much success. We should move forward as well.

In closing, I hope that this series has inspired some students to request and seek out acute care rotations. I can tell you from my personal experience, the acute care internship was the iron that sharpened the blade of my clinical judgment to its finest point as a new graduate.

Friday, April 26, 2013

Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access (Part 3)

Continued from Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access (Part 2)

Case #3

While POD#2 for a total knee replacement is still just a tad early for considering a DVT/PE, NEVER rule it out. In fact, there was suspicion in 2010 regarding the Wells Criteria in that the application of the criteria was not as predictive for inpatient populations. Why? Well, they aren't as ambulatory or normally functioning as outpatient populations would comparatively be. The tell-tale-signs in this case was the elevated heart rate & elevated respiratory rate. Whenever the lungs are slacking, the heart must work harder to push more oxygenated blood around the body. Similarly, whenever the heart is slacking, the lungs must work harder to better enrich the circulatory system with hopeful oxygen to get around. This combined with the swelling in the knee and difficulty with exertion would prime the mind to suspect a cardiopulmonary factor. Interestingly enough, the subsequent Doppler demonstrated the DVT while the CT did not show PE's.

This is where I jump on my soap box regarding too much reliance on diagnostic imaging. In the end, ANY imaging analysis is only as good as three factors: (1) the technology (resolution, focus, contrast, etc); (2) the view of the image (angle, perspective, etc); and, (3) the viewer of the image itself (human error). I tell nearly all my patients who are fixated on imaging that, in the end, it is no different than photography: if I were to hide my hand behind a book, the image would tell you my hand is a book. Diagnostic imaging should help our physical examinations, not determine them. Ultimately, the patient is the rule - not the picture.

Case #4
This is one of my very favorite acute care cases (in fact, I once again came across this same set of symptoms just recently). When dealing with exertional limitations in the absence of suspicious vital signs, IMMEDIATELY back up to your basics: anatomy, physiology, fake. Now, let me first say that the bridge between the "physiology" and "fake" category are the complex links of biopsychosocial factors.

So let's work through it. Anatomy: Is there anything wrong with this patient's anatomy? Other than the hip surgery, not at all. He is as healthy as a horse with no truly interesting medical history. We could request imaging, but, imaging of what? Besides, using imaging as a knee-jerk-response to problems is bad practice (see above soap box).

Okay, so now, we must shift our thinking to consider physiological factors. What are physiological factors of exertion? Heart, lungs, neuromuscular control, musculoskeletal integrity. Was he physically weak? Did he lose control? No and no. So lets investigate the heart and lungs. First line of defense: bust out that stethoscope!

If you performed auscultation of the heart, what you would have heard was a distinct and blatant S3 heart sound - indicative of early heart failure - one of the first classic signs, in fact. To make for a sanity check, you could have had the patient perform inspiratory and expiratory holds to make sure you weren't hearing a physiological split-S2. This patient eventually was found to be in acute renal failure. The sudden exertional fatigue was heart failure kicking in after the exercise was complete which is why the delay was present, free from any type of orthostatic hypotensive event. Fortunately, the PT in this case was able to catch this event early enough that a quick round of diuretics prevented anything permanent or serious from occurring.

Case #5
The safest thing to do when dealing with dizziness, vertigo, falls, etc. is to screen out that VBI component. Now, some individuals don't have the spinal range of motion to "officially" assess the situation. Nevertheless, you can always get creative. In the end, VBI is the inability to sufficiently circulate superiorly - so - just challenge that physiology and you will unveil at least something. For this patient, VBI screening was actually doable and positive; with reproduction of symptoms and even a scary moment of slight non-responsiveness, I decided just to do a few quick tests to discern vestibular components: nothing. An MRA was performed confirming the suspicion of VBI. While the VBI screening test isn't the most reliable test in the world, it is still one of the only tools we have in this area. What should probably speak louder than the VBI screen itself is the patient's history, age, and posture.

MORE CASES!

6. Physical Therapy Re-Evaluation: Intensive Care Unit - To Move or Not To Move
My observations have served to say that there exists a definite cultural stigma in the healthcare industry surrounding the ICU - "the unit." - as if patients are so fragile that simply touching, breathing on, or looking at them would cause something to go terribly wrong. Behind the scenes of Therapydia's PT TV Episode 12,  we brought this up and universally agreed that the attitude should NOT be of "what might go wrong if the patient gets mobilized out of bed". The attitude that would better serve the patient would be "give me a reason why I shouldn't get the patient up" - and - "what might go wrong if the patient DOESN'T get mobilized out of bed."

That said, here is the case of a male in his late 60's with a long history of COPD, A-Fib, chronic kidney disease, and valvular insufficiency. This is a great time to point out to my #DPTstudents that this trifecta almost always exists in some form (whether detectable by modern medicine or not): HEART + LUNGS + KIDNEYS (much like ears/nose/throat) - when one chain in this trifecta is broken or bent, the entire chain will become affected and will weaken. This unfortunate man was admitted to the ICU for a COPD exacerbation and had very little inspiratory reserve left to fight with. The RCP placed the patient on 10 L of oxygen with an oxymizer and was very nervous about the possibility of a physical therapist causing the patient to exert and desaturate any further than he already had. He was hanging on at this supplemental flow rate in the high 80's and low 90's in percent saturation of oxygen.

So! Do you move this patient? Will you get this patient out of bed? Is the risk worth it? What if this patient desaturates into the 70's??? What would your discussion with the RCP and the RN look like?

7. Physical Therapy Evaluation: Intensive Care Unit - Ventilated Trauma Patient
A 20 year old male suffered a terrible motorcycle accident and was fortunate enough only to sustain minor rib fractures and some minor trauma to the left shoulder (no fractures) from an orthopedic standpoint. Curiously, the patient was found in respiratory distress at the scene, and as a result, ended up ventilated with a tracheotomy. When you arrive at the room, the patient is awake, alert, following commands, and purposefully moving his extremities to reposition himself in bed. However, the RN is nervous about mobilizing the patient further than a dangle - sitting at the edge of the bed.

Do you still want to move this patient? What questions do you have for the nurse and yourself before you get inside the room? What would your discussion with the RN look like?

8. Physical Therapy Evaluation: Short Stay/Observation - Acute Low Back Pain
An electrician in his late 40's presents to the emergency department with acute low back pain and inability to ambulate without excruciating pain. He receives all the usual tests and measures with an MRI displaying a greater than 5 millimeter central disc protrusion (slightly left of midline, less than 10mm). The internist is convinced this patient will need a diskectomy and consults a spine surgeon. The nurse reiterates that the patient will likely need surgery and requests that the physical therapy evaluation be held off.

What would your discussion with the RN look like? Do you still want to treat the patient? If so, what would your treatment approach look like? Is the prognosis good? bad? ugly? indeterminante?

9. Physical Therapy Evaluation: Trauma - ATV Crash
A 40 year old male was driving an ATV and suffered a crash. He was admitted with a clean fracture of the left humerus, just distal to the surgical neck. Outside of some minor rib fractures, he was given clearance by the internist and orthopedist for home return pending a physical therapy evaluation. The fracture was deemed as reducible and thus not requiring open reduction; the orthopedist had the arm splinted citing that the majority of cases involving these types of clean fractures will heal without the need for surgery.

All systems checked out within normal limits except for the fact that the patient kept complaining that his arm felt like it was in two separate pieces. He's rather frightened about returning home tomorrow morning and is seeking your advice regarding these sensations. Also, functionally, he qualifies for home return with spouse.

What do you wish to further investigate? Do you suspect the splinting has failed? Or, is this just sensory noise from the trauma and inflammation? Should you recommend this patient to be sent home?


The results of these cases and more cases to come on Part 4 of Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access!

Monday, April 22, 2013

Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access (Part 2)


Case #1: Vertigo... or something more?
With vertigo, what do we typically run to? All your BPPV tools, right? If you ran through all these tests, performed the head thrust, oculomotor assessments, screened out for VBI... all these tests would have given the same result: nystagmus that lasted for minutes at a time, with and without torsional components. And, sure, the patient was complaining of vertigo the entire time as well. What should catch the clinician's eye immediately was the picture I posted in Part 1: Horner's syndrome.

While we're not tapeworms and therefore have given norms for amounts of asymmetry, the clinical eye should widen a bit when a history of CVA is combined with a fall plus vertigo. Now while the patient's Horner's syndrome was not as pronounced as the picture posted, it was definitely present enough for the nurse, the wife, and myself to raise suspicion. Coordination, as would be suspected, was absolutely terrible. Strength was bilaterally strong. Stance, balance, and attempts at ambulation were nothing short of terrifying - the patient simply did not have control over his movements. Did he go home? NO WAY. In fact, I held discharge and insisted on another MRI. In the end, this patient went to the acute rehab unit for several weeks.
Diagnosis: PICA syndrome. What was neat (for me) about this case was that I called out a posterior cerebellar stroke prior to seeing any imaging. What was a bit ironic is that the repeat MRI was practically identical to the admitting MRI. In fact, later in the day (after my evaluation) when the MRI became available, I pointed out the area in question to the nurse who was then quite convinced of my assessment. Oh, yes! Most importantly, the patient even said that all this felt like a stroke - just a "different" type of stroke. Lessons: listen to your patient, always make your own calls, if it smells/feels/looks/acts like a duck - it IS!

Case #2: Acute Low Back Pain with Suspicious Hip Range of Motion
The event: Sign of the buttock. While not following the classical criteria, it should pique some curiosity when anything close to the sign of the buttock presents itself. I made the attending physician aware of the constellation of symptoms and signs that I found, expressing concerns that an x-ray was likely not thorough enough to uncover the physiological root cause of this patients range of complaints. An MRI was ordered. Most unfortunately, the radiologist reported that metastatic cancer had developed throughout the patient's pelvic and lumbar region, quickly spreading into the the thoracic spine. In fact, there were several small compression fractures that had developed due to the cancer. Direct access isn't just about improving the welfare of society by freeing up economic markets; for the healthcare provider, it also means keeping an eye out for the rare but tragic and sinister health events - hopefully, there are times when we can catch it early enough and save lives.

See below for two related publications:

Ok. Back to the cases!

3. Physical Therapy Treatment: Total Knee Replacement, Post-Op-Day #2 (POD #2)
A man in his early 70's is on POD#2 of his second knee replacement (on the contralateral side of the first). His first knee replacement was only a couple years ago and was met with sterling success. However, these past few days were met with frustrations of orthostatic hypotension, slightly more swelling at the knee than expected (but within acceptable norms), and a copious amount of pain at the surgical site which was far more threatening to the patient's consciousness than was his first knee replacement. On POD#2, PM treatment, the patient began having difficulty with exertion. In-room-ambulation was fairly easy at supervision with a walker POD#1 PM and POD#2 AM. Although blood pressure was stable, the patient's heart rate was significantly elevated; respiratory rate was also elevated with a slight decrease in oxygen saturation. The nurse and the telemetry technician noted that other than the elevated heart rate, the heart did not seem to be displaying any abnormal signals.

The orthopedic surgeon is now frustrated, concerned, and is asking you - the physical therapist - what do you think is going on. What do you tell him? (Please, don't say, "You're the doctor... you tell me!" That's an automatic FAIL if you rotate with me).

4. Physical Therapy Treatment: Total Hip Replacement, POD#3 AM
A very strong, former high-level-athlete is receiving his first total hip replacement. He is in his early 60's and has been demonstrating the most impressive physical feats post-op. However, he keeps coming across this strange "wall" of fatigue and exhaustion approximately 15 minutes after he completes gait training. His orthostatic vitals demonstrated within normal limits throughout his stay. However, he is becoming increasingly anxious regarding this sudden fatigue that washes over him while he rests in his bedside chair, after he completes his ambulation. In fact, one episode performed with nursing got so bad that the patient was forced to lay back down in bed. He expressed after the episode that he felt like he was going to pass out. When the nurses checked his vitals, there were all normal.

What do you want to check? Do you wish to order any diagnostics if you were the provider? What do you think is going on?

5. Physical Therapy Evaluation: Status-Post-Fall
A severely kyphotic and osteoporotic woman in her late 80's is admitted to the hospital's short stay observation unit due to a possible syncopal episode resulting in a fall. The physicians have ruled out any cardiac factors and are now suspecting a mechanical fall in the patient's bathroom. Per usual practice, a physical therapist was consulted to further evaluate the situation and rule out any neuromusculoskeletal contributive factors. The evaluation revealed nothing out of the ordinary - not even orthostatic hypotention.

However, when cervical range of motion was screened, the patient complained of some neck pain and a small amount of dizziness. Due to the woman's slightly impaired memory, she is unable to give you a definitive history of the fall. She did mention that in the past, she was treated by a physical therapist for vertigo.

What is your most acute concern at this point? How do you confirm this suspicion? What special test/imaging/diagnostic test would you order if you were the provider?

The results of these cases and more cases to come on Part 3 of Acute Care: Preparing Students for Direct Access!